Ou se trouvent elles?
Published on January 29, 2004 By O G San In Politics
It was with disgust, though not surprise, that I noticed the red carpet being rolled out for Chinese president Hu Jintao in yet another western capital this week. Not London or Washington this time but Paris, birthplace of democracy and the site of the revolution whose timeless slogan is quoted above. As on previous trips abroad Mr. Hu was given the mildest of rebukes by his host for his country’s APPALLING human rights record. As on previous occasions this “polite” diplomacy will bring no relief to China’s thousands of political prisoners.

All this was unfortunately only to be expected. What was new this time, and in that sense more depressing, was Jacques Chirac’s full-throated support for China’s attempt to undermine the democratic process in Taiwan. By way of background, the island state goes to polls in March to elect a president. On the same day voters will have the chance for the first time to participate in a referendum. The Taiwanese government is asking its people if they wish China to stop pointing 400 missiles at them. Of course one doesn’t need to be a genius to guess the result of this poll. That’s not the point. China fears not the question but the referendum itself. Beijing sees this, correctly in my view, as the first step on the road from de facto to de jure independence for Taiwan.

We should not be surprised that the Chinese Communist Party is afraid of Chinese democracy in action. What has been depressing is the opposition of democratic states in Europe and North America to Taiwan’s first referendum. Chirac even has the gall to describe a referendum calling for military de-escalation “provocative”. Are the missiles themselves not provocative in the first place?

I suppose I should not be surprised. As I outlined in my last blog, western politicians have been kowtowing to China for decades in order to gain access to their markets. Part of the price for this access is accepting Beijing’s “one China” dogma, conveniently ignoring the fact that there are two Chinas.

As I said, we should expect no more from greedy western politicians. However the optimist in me hopes that Chirac might pause, perhaps on Bastille Day itself, to reflect on his attitude to Taiwan. Liberte, Egalite, Fraternite. Does one find these virtues in Taipei or in Beijing? The answer is obvious

Comments
on Jan 29, 2004
You are totally right, the behaviour of chirac is showing how much he is caring of the french motto. The way that protestor have been treated remind me what happen to London when GWB visit UK the last time when Large areas of london were closed to pedestrian, car, and any intruders that could bear some dissents. This is real politics, just for doing some lip service to the future master of the world...
You shouldn't be surprised, lately chirac gave some award to Ben Ali, tunisian president who has an appaling record of human right. Like a lot of politician, Chirac does't have to much principle, except the will to be reelected...
on Jan 29, 2004
How have the protesters been handled? Haven't seen anything on that. When Hu was in London the police were tearing down pro-Tibet banners - bet that made him feel right at home.
on Jan 29, 2004
As I'm not currently in France,it's quiet hard to say, but it seems from what I've been reading that some part of Paris were closed to everything, so the people couldn't demonstrate anywhere close to him. Subways stations have also been closed, so you can imagine the mess in the city centre.
But it's not for nothing, a lot of contract have been signed, a lot of money is going to be traded. Are human right that important?
on Jan 29, 2004
A little thing,
"Ou se trouvent elles ?" is the correct syntax
on Jan 29, 2004
Thanks, I was about to ask
on Jan 30, 2004
After readi9ng the morning news, it turn out that taiwan has broken diplomatic relationship with France, with the vice president defining Chirac as a saleman. The reasons came from the reprobation by chirac of the referendum supposed to happen in spring about Taiwan relationsip to China... Well played